Facebook (4.5 out of 5)

            Based on the opinion of 178 people

Jan Wagner Throgmartin

Chris McElwee

Have worked with Carter multiple times: purchases, repairs, apprasials, and have always been pleased. His service is outstanding as well as the products avaliable, which range from standard jewelry pieces to estate

Todd Johnson

Carter puts love and passion for his customers in everything he creates

Meagan Hauck Schlegel— 5 stars

I can't tell you how much I love this ring...an original Hofmeister creation...very unique and one of the prettiest rings I've seen! Such creative talent! Lauren and Pete were wonderful to work with in recreating a new setting for my wedding ring. It was a painless and fun process working with these experts. Very fair pricing might I add! They made sure every detail was perfect! Let me say that the end result of this ring far exceeded my expectations. This ring is made extremely well...built to last. My main center diamond isn't going anywhere! Thank you to the entire staff for the great experience and the incredibly unique and beautiful wedding ring. Of course I will be back to shop sometime soon! Highly recommend Hofmeister's!

David Durbin— 5 stars

Ordered dangly earrings for the wife for something different and the price point was fantastic! then asked for custom dangly earrings for a niece using our birthstone and again, not disappointed! You ask, they do, and they get it right every time!!

Hofmeister is now my only jeweler 


Andrea Cotton— 5 stars

We have been shopping at Hofmeister Jewelers almost 30 years. They have some of the most unique jewelry I have ever seen. I love wearing my original designs by Hofmeister's and I get so many compliments on them. Fun place to shop!


Justin Coleman— 5 stars

Great people! Would highly recommend working with them.


Carol Wellman— 5 stars

The Hofmeister folks are so clever with their clues AND THEY HAVE AWESOME STONES . For me that means pearls for my birthday and their pearls are top of the line .


Audra Gipson

Hofmeister personal jeweler is, hands down, the best jewelry store in Indianapolis. Unlike any other jeweler we tried in Indy, Hofmeister helped me get the exact personalized engagement ring I wanted in my price range! (Everywhere else tried to talk me out of using my grandma's diamond and had outrageous mark ups if I did choose to use it) My husband found the perfect wedding band and we got solid advice on choice of metals that would withstand his working environments! 
Thanks Lauren and Pete, we will
Never go anywhere else for our jewelry needs.


Chad Allison 

Design Award winning Chad Allison diamond medallion available at Hofmeister Personal Jewelers! See what the craze is about!



Meredith Mimi Muller LeGrand‎ 

The most beautiful ring ever made.... Thank you Hofmeister Personal Jewelers and Carter Hofmeisterfor making my dream a reality. I love all my jewelry from your store! Will NEVER shop anywhere else ever again.


Jaime Phillips Hampton

This was my prize for my golden ticket - a gorgeous black pearl ring. Thanks so much Hofmeister! I love it!


Doug Sellers 

Customer brought this in for some loving.Touched up the millgrain and refinished


Doug Sellers‎ 

Carter had our designer draw some artwork for us to make in the shop here's one we did today.Come see it the pic doesn't do it justice.


Monica Eaton‎ — 5 stars

Paid the Hofmeister family a visit last weekend on our 15th anniversary. We intended on choosing a sapphire and diamond ring to mark the occasion and ended up with not only the sapphire, but we also had my original engagement ring (also purchased at Hofmeister) re-set! The personal service received by Carter HofmeisterLauren Angeline Hofmeister and Chase Hofmeister is simply a bonus to the gorgeous, top-quality jewelry selection they provide. The experience, top-to-bottom, is second to NONE! Thank you so much!


  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Pinterest Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon
  • Instagram Social Icon